MYTH 5 – We have all the data we need for DORA scenario testing

Antony Bream
Antony Bream
DORA Lead, Gieom
November 18, 2024 •

There is nothing new about financial institutions needing to conduct scenario testing to evidence operational resilience and regulatory compliance – typically utilising synthetic and anonymised data, because live client data can’t be shared externally. However, the notion that synthetic data can be used to scenario test across all 5 Pillars of DORA is a myth because the data needed to test third-party risk in a meaningful, realistic way has to be live.

Pillar 1 of the Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) is ICT Risk Management. Firms must diligently test the operational resilience, compliance status, financial health, business processes and money laundering/cyber-attack readiness of third-party providers, on an ongoing basis. They need to know how a breach or significant weakness could impact their clients, their business or the financial sector as a whole.

More than 50% of EU financial institutions rely on US-based cloud service providers for business continuity – and we’ve seen outages. We’ve also seen the “CrowdStrike effect” – the universal operational resilience impact of a seemingly innocuous, routine software update. And numerous instances of wholesale cybersecurity failures that have been costly and reputationally damaging.

DORA regulators expect firms to be able to resolve operational resilience failures quickly and appropriately, off-board existing service providers if they pose a risk and on-board replacement providers in a controlled and timely manner, without threatening business continuity.

Today, restoring service after a digital operational resilience failure can take days; the monetary impact and disruption caused can be catastrophic. And when a critical supplier fails it can take several years to replace them. Realistic scenario testing is vital because these timescales are unlikely to pacify DORA regulators.

Data changes daily, meaning that only live, dynamic data will suffice. Those who continue to believe the myth that synthetic data will enable realistic DORA scenario testing cannot meet regulators’ expectations.

THE RISK OF BELIEVING THE MYTH

Firms denying the need to source live data to test the digital operational resilience of third-party ICT service providers cannot be accountable for their supply chain.

Their scenario testing is likely to be incomplete and/or inaccurate, putting their business and its stakeholders at risk.

Failure to use the “right” (aka live) data for supply chain scenario testing can result in a raft of damaging outcomes that firms will be keen to avoid:

THE REALITY

Never before have financial institutions had to conduct such extensive third-party risk scenario testing or evidence such tight control over the supply chain. They are poorly equipped to do so.

And never before have ICT service providers had to evidence to financial services clients and regulators that they have operational resilience built in, and processes to act appropriately when incidents arise.

One option is to source the required live data manually. However, this would take a great deal of time, be very costly and seem counterproductive given that specialist data firms can provide instant access to billions of live data points.

The kinds of live, real-time third-party data that is readily available include:

  • Financial health: Is there any insolvency risk? Have they been involved in a merger or acquisition – or are they likely to be?
  • Operational resilience infrastructure: Have they (or their onward supply chain) been involved in an operational resilience incident previously? Are they certified for other frameworks and standards, such as NIST, ITIL and ISO?
  • Senior manager risk: Has there been CEO churn? Are there any Directors with conflicts of interest? What is their background and track record? Has anyone been subject to conduct risk sanctions?
  • Cyber risk: Have they (or their onward supply chain) experienced a cyber attack in the past? How was that managed? What was the impact? Did this open a back door for bad actors to access client data? Did the CTO resign?
  • Employee retention: What is the staff turnover rate? Is there excessive retirement or flight risk? Does the firm have robust succession plans?

Only by integrating live data seamlessly with your governance, risk and compliance (GRC) or DORA compliance platform will financial institutions be able to evidence comprehensive DORA coverage and complete oversight of suppliers.

Live, real-time data enables real-world scenario testing that generates meaningful, realistic and assured results. Many firms will undoubtedly discover risks they were previously unaware of, enabling a more proactive approach to safeguarding your business, its senior managers and key stakeholders.

Download our "7 Myths about DORA compliance" eBook to reveal all 7 myths now.



Explore more
MYTH 1 – We coped with COVID, so job done on resilience
October 8, 2024
MYTH 1 – We coped with COVID, so...
One disturbing trend in recent years, which regulators have been aware of,...
MYTH 4 – We can run our operational resilience controls off a spreadsheet
November 5, 2024
MYTH 4 – We can run our operational...
There’s nothing wrong with spreadsheets. They have underpinned regulatory compliance since the...
MYTH 5 – We have all the data we need for DORA scenario testing
November 18, 2024
MYTH 5 – We have all the data...
There is nothing new about financial institutions needing to conduct scenario testing...